"Finance is the language of business decisions." True,
or merely the imperialistic mindset of the MBA at work? Agree
or disagree, without some common language, decisions
will not be made, and finance is at least a language tied to relatively
objective facts.
A common language, as I’ve noted, often seems to be lacking between
IT and lawyers, and I suggested that a joint IT/lawyer advisory
council could help ameliorate that problem. Now let’s dimensionalize
how that might work a little more clearly.
In corporate-land, the primary antagonist of IT is usually the
CFO. IT overspends, underdelivers, can’t present credible
ROI numbers for any of its projects, wants to grow its headcount
and budget faster than the rest of the company, is (kiss of death!)
a "cost center," and you can add further counts to the indictment
as you wish. So what are companies doing about it? According
to McKinsey, they’re forcing dialogue: The number of CIO’s
reporting to the CFO doubled in 2003, and McKinsey expects the
trend to continue.
What’s going on here? The goal is to give CIO’s the proverbial
"seat at the table," and to bring them into strategic planning
for the firm while they can still have an impact. In practice,
the CFO usually doesn’t really grok IT—and he’s not about
to learn. That means that if the CIO is to have a voice,
he better be able to speak financial-ease. Some companies,
like Saucony (the athletic shoe-maker) have solved the problem
by hiring a CIO and a head of MIS with pure finance backgrounds,
according to this CFO article. Less
radically, other companies simply ensure that business line-managers
are involved in deciding what IT initiatives to undertake so that
they perforce reflect the firm’s strategic direction (and have
"buy-in" before they’re even born).
Strategy is the key word. If your CIO not only can think
strategically, but has a mandate to do so, "alignment"
with the CFO is, barring personal-chemistry malfunctions, guaranteed. Uniting
finance, IT, and strategy can bring about what could be called
"budget-conscious strategic advantage:" A competitive
distinction supported by IT infrastructure developed under rigorous
financial scrutiny.
And, in case you were wondering, I thoroughly endorse the opening
quote. For business decisions, finance is the first and last
word.
(For personnel, community- or family-related, ethical,
and many other decisions, finance should barely be allowed to look
over your shoulder—just for the record, and so you don’t
think me an unreconstructed capitalist; but those decisions are
beyond the scope of this blog.)
Don’t read these magazines!
Which story is easier to tell? The story told by well-dressed sales executives who have large marketing budgets and all of the wonderful things they do for their clients or the story told by poorly-dressed technologists who sit in small…